NHL News: Draft lottery winner is a huge underdog

New York isn't usually an underdog in any context, but their two NHL teams faced long odds at this year's draft lottery. The Islanders (10th, 3.5 percent) and Rangers (11th, 3 percent) were looking up at nine other teams with better odds of landing the first pick Monday.
HOLY SCHNIKES IS RIGHT pic.twitter.com/Yz7TQ6Kb3O
— New York Islanders (@NYIslanders) May 5, 2025
Start spreading the news: the Islanders will pick first in June.
RELATED: Recently retired sportscasting legend wins prestigious award
After a season that saw the Isles go 35-35-12 and provide few highlights — other than being on the receiving end of Alex Ovechkin's 895th career goal — an unexpected reward will come in the form of the best player in this year's draft.
WE KNEW IT WAS GONNA BE A GOOD NIGHT WHEN THIS GUY SHOWED UP. pic.twitter.com/SU0gZgf3mY
— New York Islanders (@NYIslanders) May 5, 2025
Matthew Schaefer, a defenseman for the Ontario Hockey League's Erie (Pa.) Otters, is the consensus number-1 pick.
The draft "loser" is the San Jose Sharks. After posting the worst record in the league at 20-50-12, the Sharks had the best odds of any team going into the lottery selection Monday at 18.5 percent. They will draft second.
Just in: The Sharks will pick No. 2 in the 2025 #NHLDraft!#TheFutureIsTeal pic.twitter.com/rCEZs60XKT
— San Jose Sharks (@SanJoseSharks) May 5, 2025
Don't feel too bad for Team Teal: they drafted first overall a year ago, and landed 25-goal scorer Macklin Celebrini.
The Utah Hockey Club won the second draw, but because NHL teams can only improve their standing by 10 slots in the lottery, they will pick fourth. Utah had a 1.5 percent chance at landing the number-1 pick in the draft.
More news: NHL team might abandon radio broadcasts in largest U.S. media market: report
The NBA instituted the first draft lottery by a major North American professional sports league in 1985. The NHL followed 10 years later.
The Islanders have only made two number-1 selections in the lottery era: forward John Tavares (2009) and goaltender Rick DiPietro (2000).
GET MORE TOP STORIES from The Big Lead by subscribing to TBL YouTube channel
WEEKEND ROUNDUP:Derby winner, NBA Playoffs heat up, don't sleep on puck, and more
CFB: College football's most toxic fan bases revealed
MLB: Pirates fan making 'significant progress' in hospital after 20-foot fall
NBA:Warriors rescued by unlikely record-setting hero in Game 7 win over Rockets
NFL: President Donald Trump set to reveal the 2027 NFL Draft location
SPORTS MEDIA:'Saturday Night Live' roasts Bill Belichick & Jordon Hudson relationship