The Edmonton Oilers spent the 2025-26 NHL season chasing solutions, but one move continues to define their collapse.
Speaking on the “Spittin Chiclets” podcast, former NHL forward and analyst Paul Bissonnette ripped Edmonton’s decision to move defenseman Brett Kulak, calling the organization ‘stupid’ after Kulak helped power the Colorado Avalanche into the Western Conference Final.
“Colorado had the depth,” Bissonnette said. “The depth in the last two games really showed up. Parker Kelly, Drury, who was a throw-in on the Necas trade, he was huge. Great fourth-line center. Wow. And then, Kulak. Kulak logged more five-on-five ice than Cale Makar in that series, boys, in five games. So, to the Edmonton Oilers, you guys are fucked. You guys are stupid. Stupid, stupid.”
The injury bug hit the Wild HARD. pic.twitter.com/P0f92zzQfk
— Spittin' Chiclets (@spittinchiclets) May 17, 2026
The comments came after Colorado eliminated the Minnesota Wild in five games. Kulak scored the overtime winner in Game 5 after the Avalanche erased a 3-0 deficit. The veteran defenseman also broke up a dangerous pass from Kirill Kaprizov moments earlier, capping one of the strongest playoff performances of his career.
MORE: NHL analyst blasted over Connor McDavid is ‘gone’ prediction
Oilers created a problem they could not fix
Edmonton traded Kulak in December as part of a cap-clearing deal for goaltender Tristan Jarry. The move also sent their previous starting goalie, Stuart Skinner, and a draft pick away, with management betting Jarry could stabilize the crease.
Instead, the Oilers lost one of their steadiest playoff defenders and received inconsistent goaltending in return. Jarry posted a 3.86 goals-against average and an .858 save percentage for the Oilers, while Edmonton’s defensive structure completely unraveled. The club finished 25th in goals against during the regular season and exited the playoffs in six games against the Anaheim Ducks.
The failure exposed a larger issue inside Edmonton’s roster construction. Kulak handled difficult defensive assignments for years without much attention. Once he left, younger replacements failed to manage those minutes, playing a part in Edmonton’s defensive failure against the Ducks.
Colorado identified the depth role, which Edmonton overlooked

Colorado’s front office identified exactly what it lacked at the deadline. The Avalanche added Kulak for stability, penalty killing, and defensive reliability. What followed was a perfect fit inside a structured, balanced lineup.
That contrast matters. While Edmonton leaned heavily on injured stars like Connor McDavid and Leon Draisaitl, Colorado kept rolling four lines and trusted its entire blue line. Kulak’s ability to absorb heavy even-strength minutes allowed players like Cale Makar to stay aggressive offensively.
MORE: NHL Trade Rumors: Oilers’ $74M D-man gets linked to Sharks
Bissonnette’s delivery was harsh, but the underlying point holds weight. Championship teams rarely move dependable playoff defensemen unless the return clearly upgrades the roster. Edmonton did the opposite.
One season after back-to-back Stanley Cup Final appearances, the Oilers became a cautionary example of how quickly depth erosion can undo a contender.