NFL fans are questioning Nicolas Cage’s portrayal of John Madden after Prime Video released a new teaser for “Madden,” the upcoming biopic. The 38-second clip sparked criticism online, with viewers questioning whether Cage captured the legendary coach and broadcaster’s voice and personality.
Prime Video shared the teaser on X with the caption, “And football commentary was never the same.”
The scene features Cage as Madden in the broadcast booth alongside Pat Summerall. In the scene, Madden uses a piece of glass and a sketch pen, calling it a “telestrator” to explain the Green Bay Packers’ power sweep, a play associated with former Packers coach Vince Lombardi. The sequence attempts to capture Madden’s animated approach to football analysis.
And football commentary was never the same. #MaddenMovie. November 18. pic.twitter.com/ywUVTnYtkf
— Prime Movies (@primemovies) October 27, 2026
However, the portrayal failed to convince many fans who watched the clip.
Pro Football Talk reacted bluntly, writing, “This is going to be a shame.”
One fan questioned Cage’s performance, saying, “I was wondering how Nicolas Cage was going to pull off being Madden. Turns out he didn’t pull it off at all.”
Another viewer called the performance “a disgraceful portrayal of a great man.”
Nicolas Cage’s voice becomes a major talking point

NFL analyst Lance Zierlein also criticized the teaser, writing, “This looks crazy terrible.”
Bills reporter Ryan Talbot focused on Cage’s voice, suggesting it sounded nothing like Madden.
“Nicolas Cage’s John Madden voice is literally just Nicolas Cage,” Talbot wrote. “This is going to be one of those movies that is so bad that it’s good. I can just tell.”
NFL analyst Adam Kaufman shared similar doubts despite his appreciation for Cage. “Man, I love Cage, but I just don’t understand how this happened,” he wrote.
One particularly frustrated fan demanded accountability, saying, “There are going to have to be arrests. Accountability for this is a must.”
The criticism centers on Madden’s distinctive personality and his importance to football culture. He was a Super Bowl-winning coach, an influential broadcaster and the namesake of the popular Madden NFL video game franchise.
A fan wrote, “I’m sorry, but this just looks absolutely awful. He doesn’t look or sound anything like John Madden. He sounds like Jimmy Stewart or something. I said it before and I’ll say it again; Nick Cage was a horrible pick to play John Madden.”
MORE: Former Packers linebacker, Super Bowl champion, dies
The film, directed by David O. Russell, also stars Christian Bale as Raiders owner Al Davis. It is scheduled to arrive in select theaters on Nov. 11 before streaming on Prime Video on Nov. 18.
The teaser has clearly divided viewers before release. Whether the full film changes their minds remains to be seen.
— Enjoy free coverage of the top news & trending stories with The Big Lead Newsletter —