The Toronto Maple Leafs could become a potential landing spot for Erik Karlsson if the Pittsburgh Penguins defenseman reaches the NHL trade market.
Speaking on the “32 Thoughts” podcast, Elliotte Friedman shared a prediction that Karlsson could eventually join Toronto. The veteran defenseman enters the final year of his $92 million contract, making his future an interesting storyline.
“One guy said to me, ‘I have a 2026-27 prediction for you,’” Friedman said. “ I said, ‘OK, what is it?’ And he goes, ‘My prediction is Erik Karlsson becomes a Toronto Maple Leaf, depending on how both teams’ seasons go.’ I was like, ‘Oh, that’s a good idea.’”
MORE: Ex-Maple Leafs enforcer claims Morgan Rielly was ‘panicking’ last season
Friedman noted that Penguins GM Kyle Dubas previously tried to acquire Karlsson while serving as Toronto’s general manager. Dubas later brought Karlsson to Pittsburgh during his tenure with the Penguins.
“He’s always liked him,” Friedman said, while highlighting Karlsson’s strong 2025-26 season. The 36-year-old recorded 15 goals and 66 points through 75 regular-season games.
Karlsson also contributed three points in six playoff games. His offensive production restored some of the impact associated with his Norris Trophy-winning career.
Erik Karlsson would fit Maple Leafs’ need for puck movement

Toronto’s interest would depend heavily on cost and roster structure. Karlsson can still drive offense from the blue line, but his age and contract make the decision more complicated.
Friedman said he believes Pittsburgh’s performance could determine whether Karlsson becomes available. “If Pittsburgh has another good year like they did last year and Karlsson plays like he did, I don’t know that I see him getting traded at all,” he said.
Erik Karlsson ➡️ Toronto?
— Sportsnet (@Sportsnet) August 25, 2026
In a surprise edition of 32 Thoughts, @sportsnetkyle and @FriedgeHNIC break down the latest from around the league.
🎧: https://t.co/5gqXx41hdj pic.twitter.com/yC2q5mAvnT
That creates a clear condition for Toronto. The Maple Leafs would need Pittsburgh to fall from contention while Karlsson remains productive enough to attract playoff teams.
Toronto has already reshaped its roster after missing the playoffs last season. Adding Karlsson would give the team another elite puck-moving option and increase offensive creativity from the back end.
However, his contract carries significant weight. Pittsburgh must also consider Karlsson’s no-move clause before any potential deal develops.
Friedman framed the possibility alongside Toronto’s link with Swedish hockey stars. “Mats Sundin, Daniel Alfredsson, Erik Karlsson, Toronto,” he said, pointing to Sundin and Alfredsson, who hold different roles with the current Maple Leafs group.
For now, Karlsson remains a Penguin. But if Pittsburgh’s season changes direction, Toronto could become an intriguing destination.
— Enjoy free coverage of the top news & trending stories with The Big Lead Newsletter —