Every draft has a moment when the smart managers start smiling. It’s the point when the big names are gone, and the room forgets that value hides in the later rounds. That’s where you win. In the NFL, the quarterback position is critical, but the same isn’t true for your fantasy football roster.
On draft day, you’ll find a ton of undervalued fantasy football sleepers whose average draft position does not match their upside, and the four names below are undervalued for reasons that have more to do with old headlines than fresh evidence.
Each one brings a mix of rushing production, new weapons or a friendly system. Grab one late, skip the early-round tax and let everyone else pay full price for a name.
More: Jon Gruden gives roster advice, high praise for Dallas Cowboys’ dynamic WR duo
Kyler Murray, Minnesota Vikings

Murray is one of the biggest fantasy football sleepers in 2026 because his average draft position sits at QB17, and that number treats him like a backup sitting on your bench instead of the undervalued dual threat he actually is.
The Vikings signed the former Cardinals passer to a fresh start with Kevin O’Connell calling plays, and O’Connell is one of the better play designers a quarterback can ask for. Murray finished as QB10 in his last full season in 2024, completing 372 passes for 3,851 yards and 21 touchdowns while adding 572 rushing yards and five scores on the ground. That rushing floor is the part managers keep ignoring.
The 5-foot-10 Oklahoma product has averaged at least 30 rushing yards per game in all seven of his NFL seasons, which is the kind of steady production that props up a fantasy week even when the passing numbers dip.
Now he throws to Justin Jefferson, Jordan Addison and Jauan Jennings, one of the deepest receiver groups in the sport. Health has been Murray’s issue, not talent, and he enters 2026 the healthiest he has been in years.
Tyler Shough, New Orleans Saints

Shough is the sleeper the fantasy community already loves, which sounds like a contradiction until you check his average draft position at QB20 or worse. The second-round rookie took over as the Saints starter in Week 9 last year and finished as QB12 in fantasy points per game the rest of the way, posting at least 17.1 points in each of his final six starts.
Across nine starts, the Louisville product threw for 2,256 yards with 10 touchdowns, completed 67.6% of his passes and averaged 7.3 yards per attempt while adding three rushing scores. That is real production for a first-year passer, and the offense around him got better. New Orleans spent the No. 8 overall pick on Arizona State wideout Jordyn Tyson to pair with Chris Olave, then signed running back Travis Etienne Jr. to deepen the backfield next to Alvin Kamara.
Head coach Kellen Moore runs a fast-paced, quarterback-friendly system, and the schedule projects as one of the softer ones in the league. Extrapolate Shough’s rookie starting numbers across a full season and he lands in the QB8 to QB12 range at an ADP that costs nothing for fantasy football managers.
Malik Willis, Miami Dolphins

Willis is the rare fantasy football sleeper who pairs a bottom-of-the-board average draft position with genuine top-12 upside, and that gap is why he is so undervalued.
Miami handed the former Packers backup a three-year, $67.5 million deal to be the starter, yet he is going as QB21, which makes him close to free in every format. The reason to buy is his legs. Since 2014, 91 percent of quarterbacks with at least 100 rushing attempts have finished as top-12 fantasy scorers, and Willis has the mobility to hit that mark.
When he scrambled as a Packer, he averaged 8.9 yards per scramble, second among projected 2026 starters only to Justin Herbert. His passing sample is small but strong. Over 159 plays across the past three seasons, the Liberty product ranks first among 79 qualifiers in EPA per play and first in completion percentage over expected.
His Week 17 audition last season, 18-of-21 for 288 yards plus 60 rushing yards and two touchdowns, is the ceiling everyone can picture. Feeling bold? Stack him with running back De’Von Achane and the upside is obvious at a price nobody else wants to pay.
Daniel Jones, Indianapolis Colts

Jones is a trickier sleeper because his average draft position is climbing, but the discount is still there for managers who read the fine print on his 2025 tape. Before a torn Achilles ended his season in Week 14, the Colts quarterback was having the best year of his career, ranking as the overall QB9 while completing 68% of his throws for 3,101 yards and 19 touchdowns across 10 games.
He averaged 253.4 passing yards, 13.3 rushing yards and 2.0 total touchdowns per game, the profile of a locked-in QB1 when healthy. The former Giants first-round pick signed a two-year extension to stay in Indianapolis through 2027, and last year’s SportsLine model correctly predicted his breakout in his first season with the Colts.
The catch is the injury timeline. Jones is working his way back and appears to be tracking toward Week 1, though nothing is guaranteed, so anyone drafting him should pair him with a reliable second quarterback in case the early weeks slip.
The upside is a proven top-10 fantasy passer, and that combination of a settled role and rushing production is worth the wait.