Dragon’s Dogma 2 Dark Arisen has a bit of a complex story, though it doesn’t seem that way at first. After encountering an immortal dragon, you discover that in order to defeat it, you must first destroy its bones. However, after venturing into a hidden castle to find said bones, you find that they are actually the remains of this mysterious other Arisen that sent you to Norgan in the first place.
Ser Eir, who has been helping you up until now, reveals that they are a Pawn of this Arisen and seeks to find a way to restore them, which is in direct conflict with your goal of destroying the dragon.
It appears you have a choice to make, and we’ll explain which one you should make. It’s not the only choice you’ll have to make in this DLC either, but for a lower-stakes example, check out what to give Freki in A Direwolf’s Delicacy.
Table of contents
If you destroy the Arisen – DD2 Dark Arisen

The information you heard is correct; destroying the Arisen does indeed deal with the dragon, but it’s more a case of removing the problem instead of solving the problem. Eir will try her best to prevent you from doing it and will not look favourably upon you after the fact, but many questions will go unanswered, and you’ll miss out on the DLC’s true ending.
If you spare the Arisen – DD2 Dark Arisen
Eir will be extremely grateful, and you will immediately set out on a renewed quest to find a way to destroy the Fallen Dragon in a different way. To say much more would be spoiling the rest of the DLC beyond this point, but this is the path that puts you on the true ending.
Should you destroy or spare the Arisen? – DD2 Dark Arisen
There’s no question here: sparing the Arisen is the correct choice, and clearly the one you’re expected to make. It leads to the story developing properly and you actually getting the answers to many of the mysteries this DLC sets up.