Craig Berube says he shouldn’t have ‘appeased’ Maple Leafs players

Toronto Maple Leafs forward Auston Matthews (34), defenseman Morgan Rielly (44), forward William Nylander (88), and forward John Tavares (91) huddle before a face-off against the Tampa Bay Lightning during the second period at Benchmark International Arena. Mandatory Credit: Morgan Tencza-Imagn Images

Former Toronto Maple Leafs head coach Craig Berube has offered a candid reflection on his failed tenure, admitting he compromised too much while trying to reshape the team’s identity.

Berube was hired by the Maple Leafs in May 2024 and was fired on May 13, 2026. During his tenure, he coached the Maple Leafs to a 78-66-20 NHL regular-season record and a 4-7 playoff record, winning just one playoff series.

MORE: Craig Berube delivers candid verdict on Maple Leafs losing Mitch Marner

Speaking on Leafs Morning Take, Berube said he regretted easing his demands after initially pushing players outside their comfort zones. He explained that his goal from day one was to install a playoff-style system built on structure and physical commitment.

“Well, I definitely went in there from the get-go when I was first hired to try to get them out of a comfort zone and play a different style of hockey, a style that I believe is what you need to play to be successful in the playoffs,” Berube said.

Berube believed the first season showed progress despite falling short of championship standards.

“The first year I thought it was pretty good, not where we wanted it to be,” Berube said. “I’m not going to sit here and say we were great at everything. We weren’t. We had a real good year, but overall I still didn’t feel we were at a place where we could be successful enough in the playoffs to win.”

Changing course was a mistake with Maple Leafs players

Former Toronto Maple Leafs head coach Craig Berube watches the play with Auston Matthews and other players at Scotiabank Arena
Former Toronto Maple Leafs head coach Craig Berube watches the play with Auston Matthews and other players at Scotiabank Arena. Mandatory Credit: Nick Turchiaro-Imagn Images

Berube admitted he softened his approach during the following season after trying to meet players halfway.

“That’s my style of hockey and the way I feel we need to play to be successful in the playoffs,” Berube said about his first season as Leafs coach, in which the team made it to the second round of the playoffs. “It obviously didn’t work out the next year for sure.”

He said, “I mean, we tried to change a few things and tried to get players to play a little differently. I tried to appease them as much as I could. And if I had to do it all over again, I would never have done that.

Berube was clearly unhappy with the Maple Leafs’ disastrous 2025-26 campaign. The team finished 32-36-14, missed the playoffs for the first time since 2016, and suffered the largest single-season points decline in franchise history. General manager Brad Treliving lost his job before Berube was dismissed following the season.

MORE: Maple Leafs announce 2026 NHL preseason schedule featuring Canadiens, Senators

Berube’s comments underline a common coaching challenge. Successful systems require complete buy-in, especially from star players expected to set the standard. Once a coach adjusts core principles to satisfy individuals, accountability often becomes inconsistent.

Toronto’s collapse cannot be pinned solely on coaching. Injury to captain Auston Matthews, Mitch Marner’s departure, defensive struggles, and poor goaltending all played major roles. Still, Berube’s admission reveals he believes leadership starts with conviction. His experience tells that changing culture demands consistency, even when short-term resistance follows.

More From The Big Lead