NFL Draft Research Roundup
I’ve been writing random things on the internet for a while now, and for a while, I did it as a hobby while not getting compensated and doing it late at night when I could not sleep. I went back through some of the stuff I have written specifically about the draft and thought I would organize it into a roundup. I would hope some of it still has value, because I try to (while perhaps using examples from a given year) take a longer term approach to questions.
Hopefully, you’ll find something that you have an interest in.
Last year, leading up to the draft, I took a look at the typical results in the draft, to provide a dose of reality. Then, to mix things up, I had a post where I compared Moto Moto to John Elway and Tim Tebow.
In 2011 Draft Analysis: The difference between a bust, a boom, and an average pick at the top of the draft, I use career value of top draft picks to look at why teams will take risks on upside, by comparing team performance based on how good or bad the pick was. I also gave some thoughts on drafting best player available versus for need.
On a similar topic, before my time at the Big Lead, I also wrote about taking the BPA at pro-football-reference.com. The Best Player Available, I took a look at how frequently teams in the first fifty picks end up taking the “best player” compared to those taken within the next 30 picks. For top 5 picks, the answer was about 10% of the time. That may not sound great, but it is 3 times greater than if we threw all first rounders in a hat and drew randomly.
In Peter King on Eric Berry: Are Safeties Really a Risk at the Top of the Draft? I looked at the history of early safeties and found that they actually panned out at a much higher rate than most positions. I then followed up with Do Star Safeties Have Shorter Careers Than Other Positions? by looking at career longevity of young stars at each position. Safeties did have shorter careers, and I argued that this, along with their early performance, actually meant they should be attractive targets in the draft.
Do Good Teams Really Build Along the Lines? I looked at the drafting tendencies in the first round of successful teams, teams that went from bad to successful, and teams that stayed bad to see if there was any evidence to support this. I also looked at teams that devoted a heavy dose of first round picks on linemen, to see if they actually won more than other teams.
In Matt Ryan, Brian Brohm, and the Right to Choose, I took a look at how often a quarterback performs better than the next one taken in the first two rounds of the draft. Brohm ended up falling even further after I wrote that (Flacco was the next one taken after Ryan) but the general research still applies even if Brian Brohm continued to stink.
I also did a lengthy series comparing the AFL and NFL for any history buffs, and as part of that I looked at Draft Class Peaks and Declines. When do draft classes tend to peak in terms of value (overall number of starters combined with performance)? Generally in years 3 and 4.
You may also be interested in Chase Stuart’s draft value chart, right or wrong? and this interesting theoretical discussion from Doug Drinen on whether a team should prefer every fifth round pick or the #1 overall pick in a draft.
[photo via Getty]

- John Tortorella And a Ref Dropped F-Bombs On Live TV During the Rangers-Bruins Game [Video]
- LeBron James and Paul George’s Epic Game 1 Battle Looks Even Cooler in Slow Motion [Video]
- Manchester City Players Were Super Excited To Catch Passes From Eli Manning [Video]
- Miami Heat Remix of Pitbull’s “Feel This Moment?” Dále!
- Buffalo Bills Fan Has O.J. Simpson Mug Shot Tattoo on His Thigh

- orly57 on John Tortorella And a Ref Dropped F-Bombs On Live TV During the Rangers-Bruins Game [Video]
- yorwifesahor on Buffalo Bills Fan Has O.J. Simpson Mug Shot Tattoo on His Thigh
- Nada on Fox Sports 1 Heavily in Pursuit of Former NFL Player Trevor Pryce and ESPN Chicago's Sarah Spain
- Nada on Fox Sports 1 Heavily in Pursuit of Former NFL Player Trevor Pryce and ESPN Chicago's Sarah Spain
- A.P. on Buffalo Bills Fan Has O.J. Simpson Mug Shot Tattoo on His Thigh
6 Responses to “NFL Draft Research Roundup”
Leave a Reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.






April 22nd, 2012 at 9:55 AM
I won’t be able to finish all links before heading out to church, but I look forward to digging in later. Thanks for sharing & gathering these links into one post.
April 22nd, 2012 at 9:56 AM
Damnit Lisk. It’s too early Sunday morning to click on those links and comprehend your spot on commentary.
Another good post though by The Big Liskowski, aka Liskanity.
April 22nd, 2012 at 10:09 AM
Terrific caption
April 22nd, 2012 at 12:26 PM
From the in Matt Ryan, Brian Brohm, and the Right to Choose:
I thought MIA did a great job in 2008 picking him in the 2nd round for the value. Alas, it never seemed to click for Chad, whether it was coaching or scheme, he never found his rhythm in a MIA uniform.
I don’t understand, he was a 4-yr starter at major College, built like an NFL QB, can take a hit and has above avg arm., but did have his moments of brain-farts on the field. I think it was a little of both coaching & himself. Wish him the best at JAX.
April 22nd, 2012 at 11:58 PM
I did look at all the linked stories. Impressive amount of research, Lisk.
There is a lot more art and imprecise science to the drafting process than I ever realized.
FWIW, I concur with drafting “the best player available” as sound advice. So much risk drafting for need.
April 23rd, 2012 at 8:17 AM
A while ago, while taking a while on the toilet, I read this while listening to a podcast. I’ll be back in a while.