Really, why on earth would Peyton Manning waste 60 seconds of thought on being a potential Jet?

Stop with the carousel, and the flirtation with every major free agent “name” every offseason and build the fuckin team according to a blueprint the powers-that-be believe in. They started to do that and built an identity in 2009 and 2010, only to do who knows what last season. If that doesn’t work out, and Sanchez sucks worse, so be it. The Jets do not need another circus, which is exactly what will result by bringing Manning in. Ground and pound? Not with Manning…

sure, could lose with Sanchez. could win with him, too. done it before.

Everyone else thinks that the Jets won IN SPITE of Sanchez. They won because they had a lethal defense and a great running game. Now that the defense is not as lethal and the run game is a little less great, the QB can’t carry the team.

So, to be clear. You would rather lose with Sanchez than take a chance on Manning (who absolutely will not go to New York and play for Ryan), correct?

Wow.

Shouldn’t even be discussed.

Thank you. Couldn’t agree more. Wasn’t sure what the sentiment would be here, but it makes little sense on so many levels.

There’s no point in going down the Brett Favre road again.

The difference being that Favre was the Gunslinger, while Peyton is Sergeant York.

You’re right, PM jumping to a new team that got whipped by the Patriots twice last year – when the defense was garbage – would have no problem all of a sudden.

Yeah, those teams that got whipped had Mark Sanchez playing for them so…

Brawny – the cherry picking of defensive stats is hilarious. the defense has gotten worse each of the last 3 years.

What did I cherry pick? I just looked at their rank. I’ll admit its not the most accurate ranking, but 5th != increasingly bad defense

But if you have anything to add other than the J-Mac eyeball test to back up your claims, I am all ears.

TBL- Weren’t you the one on here OR on twitter talking about how you are ready to bury Sanchez? I remember it vividly to be honest.

heat-of-the-moment tweets during a game happen. I’m sure i said that, but when the smoke clears, level-headedness rules.

sure, could lose with Sanchez. could win with him, too. done it before.

They give out awards for road playoff wins? Otherwise the trophy case is pretty bare.

Pounty receiver.

What does that mean?

Its code for Sanchez was so bad last year, Holmes and Plax put a Pounty on him.

I almost think you’d rather lose with Sanchez than win with Manning.

As the post says … i’d rather give MS one more shot instead of taking a chance on Peyton. sure, could lose with Sanchez. could win with him, too. done it before.

Yes, because Peyton Manning has played so poorly against Belichick, in road games and with a dominating offensive line in recent years. Oh…wait, none of that’s true. Eh, so what.

You’re right, PM jumping to a new team that got whipped by the Patriots twice last year – when the defense was garbage – would have no problem all of a sudden.

Blaine Gabbert heartily agrees with the conclusions you’re drawing.

What does that mean?

If he’s at the point where you say give the guy one more year before you cut him, then there isn’t anything wrong with cutting strings a year early to get a Peyton Manning.

You can see TBL now after another shitty season by Sanchez “it was his first year in a new system!!!!”

I haven’t wavered in my thoughts on Sanchez: Give the guy one more year under a new offensive coordinator. If he doesn’t show improvement in 2012, then it’s time to make a move.

If he’s at the point where you say give the guy one more year before you cut him, then there isn’t anything wrong with cutting strings a year early to get a Peyton Manning.

Cross the Jets off Peyton Manning’s potential destination. Shouldn’t happen. Shouldn’t even be discussed.

Isnt discussing it EXACTLY what you are doing here?